{
  "selected": {
    "en": {
      "id": "en-real-2",
      "reason": "Listener explicitly approved this reference pair",
      "component_content_enjoyment": {
        "S1": 5.070472896099091,
        "S2": 5.0253824384417385,
        "context": 5.535616564564407
      },
      "weakest_input_ce": 5.0253824384417385
    },
    "de": {
      "id": "de-notebooklm-new",
      "reason": "Highest minimum Content Enjoyment across S1, S2 and context; mean CE breaks ties",
      "component_content_enjoyment": {
        "S1": 5.051487440243363,
        "S2": 4.980291980784386,
        "context": 5.298298366367817
      },
      "weakest_input_ce": 4.980291980784386
    },
    "fr": {
      "id": "fr-real-3",
      "reason": "Highest minimum Content Enjoyment across S1, S2 and context; mean CE breaks ties",
      "component_content_enjoyment": {
        "S1": 4.823661969974637,
        "S2": 4.88536470150575,
        "context": 5.136921991594136
      },
      "weakest_input_ce": 4.823661969974637
    },
    "es": {
      "id": "es-real-2",
      "reason": "Highest minimum Content Enjoyment across S1, S2 and context; mean CE breaks ties",
      "component_content_enjoyment": {
        "S1": 4.823661969974637,
        "S2": 4.890111065469682,
        "context": 5.103697443846613
      },
      "weakest_input_ce": 4.823661969974637
    },
    "nl": {
      "id": "nl-real-2",
      "reason": "Highest minimum Content Enjoyment across S1, S2 and context; mean CE breaks ties",
      "component_content_enjoyment": {
        "S1": 4.932828341145068,
        "S2": 4.951813797000796,
        "context": 5.3789865537546575
      },
      "weakest_input_ce": 4.932828341145068
    }
  },
  "rankings": {
    "en": [
      {
        "id": "en-real-2",
        "language": "en",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 5.070472896099091,
          "S2": 5.0253824384417385,
          "context": 5.535616564564407
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 5.0253824384417385,
        "mean_input_ce": 5.210490633035079,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049445.95102
      },
      {
        "id": "en-notebooklm-new",
        "language": "en",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 4.980291980784386,
          "S2": 4.944694251054898,
          "context": 5.421703829430044
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.944694251054898,
        "mean_input_ce": 5.115563353756443,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049445.9288428
      },
      {
        "id": "en-real-1",
        "language": "en",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 4.909096521325409,
          "S2": 5.008770164567977,
          "context": 5.179639267269522
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.909096521325409,
        "mean_input_ce": 5.032501984387636,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049445.9176881
      }
    ],
    "de": [
      {
        "id": "de-notebooklm-new",
        "language": "de",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 5.051487440243363,
          "S2": 4.980291980784386,
          "context": 5.298298366367817
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.980291980784386,
        "mean_input_ce": 5.110025929131855,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049445.935848
      },
      {
        "id": "de-real-1",
        "language": "de",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 4.970799252856523,
          "S2": 4.980291980784386,
          "context": 5.27931291051209
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.970799252856523,
        "mean_input_ce": 5.076801381384333,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049446.1176767
      },
      {
        "id": "de-real-2",
        "language": "de",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 4.753653101506643,
          "S2": 4.778571512317285,
          "context": 5.139295173576102
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.753653101506643,
        "mean_input_ce": 4.89050659580001,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049446.1485827
      }
    ],
    "fr": [
      {
        "id": "fr-real-3",
        "language": "fr",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 4.823661969974637,
          "S2": 4.88536470150575,
          "context": 5.136921991594136
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.823661969974637,
        "mean_input_ce": 4.948649554358174,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049446.3053067
      },
      {
        "id": "fr-real-2",
        "language": "fr",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 4.7667056024074554,
          "S2": 4.773825148353353,
          "context": 5.182012449251488
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.7667056024074554,
        "mean_input_ce": 4.907514400004099,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049446.2262914
      },
      {
        "id": "fr-real-1",
        "language": "fr",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 4.744160373578779,
          "S2": 4.7655190114164725,
          "context": 5.224729724926874
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.744160373578779,
        "mean_input_ce": 4.911469703307375,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049446.2167745
      }
    ],
    "es": [
      {
        "id": "es-real-2",
        "language": "es",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 4.823661969974637,
          "S2": 4.890111065469682,
          "context": 5.103697443846613
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.823661969974637,
        "mean_input_ce": 4.9391568264303105,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049446.4141886
      },
      {
        "id": "es-real-1",
        "language": "es",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 4.868752427631989,
          "S2": 4.821288787992671,
          "context": 5.208117451053113
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.821288787992671,
        "mean_input_ce": 4.966052888892591,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049446.3973503
      },
      {
        "id": "es-real-3",
        "language": "es",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 4.687204006011598,
          "S2": 4.778571512317285,
          "context": 5.2365956348367035
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.687204006011598,
        "mean_input_ce": 4.900790384388529,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049446.413037
      }
    ],
    "nl": [
      {
        "id": "nl-real-2",
        "language": "nl",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 4.932828341145068,
          "S2": 4.951813797000796,
          "context": 5.3789865537546575
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.932828341145068,
        "mean_input_ce": 5.0878762306335075,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049446.6176143
      },
      {
        "id": "nl-real-3",
        "language": "nl",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 5.037248348351568,
          "S2": 4.861632881686091,
          "context": 5.547482474474236
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.861632881686091,
        "mean_input_ce": 5.148787901503965,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049446.6011324
      },
      {
        "id": "nl-real-1",
        "language": "nl",
        "component_content_enjoyment": {
          "S1": 4.847393789794296,
          "S2": 4.956560160964727,
          "context": 5.336269278079271
        },
        "weakest_input_ce": 4.847393789794296,
        "mean_input_ce": 5.046741076279432,
        "scope": "Actual MP3 input anchors S1/S2 and chronological context, not a source target or generated output",
        "time": 1794049446.6163774
      }
    ]
  },
  "selection_uses_generated_output_scores": false,
  "ranking_rule": "Maximize the minimum EARS Content Enjoyment of all three actual input components; do not let one poor anchor hide behind a good mean",
  "english_override": "en-real-2 is human-approved and retained regardless of proxy rank"
}